India has made a historic announcement at the G20 summit in Delhi, launching a new economic corridor that will connect it with the Middle East and Europe, and challenge China’s ambitious One Belt One Road (OBOR) initiative. The India-Middle East-Europe Economic Corridor (IMEEC) is a joint venture of India, the US, the EU, Saudi Arabia and the UAE, and aims to boost trade, investment, infrastructure and cultural ties among the participating countries.

What is OBOR and why is it a threat?

OBOR is China’s grand vision to revive the ancient Silk Road, a network of trade routes that linked China with Europe and Asia for centuries. OBOR consists of two components: the land-based Silk Road Economic Belt and the ocean-based Maritime Silk Road. Together, they span over 60 countries across Asia, Africa and Europe, covering about 65% of the world’s population and 40% of the global GDP.

China claims that OBOR is a win-win proposition for all involved, offering opportunities for development, cooperation and connectivity. However, many critics see OBOR as a strategic tool for China to expand its influence, leverage its economic power, and advance its geopolitical interests. Some of the concerns include:

• OBOR projects are often financed by Chinese loans that create debt traps for the recipient countries, compromising their sovereignty and security.
• OBOR projects are often carried out by Chinese companies that bring their own workers and materials, limiting the local benefits and creating environmental and social risks.
• OBOR projects are often aligned with China’s strategic objectives, such as securing access to natural resources, building military bases, or gaining political support.

How does IMEEC differ from OBOR?

IMEEC is India’s response to OBOR, offering an alternative vision of regional integration that is based on mutual respect, transparency and inclusiveness. IMEEC has several advantages over OBOR, such as:

• IMEEC is a multilateral initiative that involves key global players such as the US and the EU, ensuring a balance of power and interests in the region.
• IMEEC is a demand-driven initiative that responds to the needs and aspirations of the partner countries, rather than imposing a predetermined agenda.
• IMEEC is a quality-driven initiative that adheres to high standards of governance, sustainability and social responsibility in its projects.

What are the benefits of IMEEC?

IMEEC has the potential to bring significant benefits to India and its partners in terms of trade, investment, infrastructure and culture. Some of the benefits include:

• IMEEC will enhance India’s connectivity with West Asia and Europe, opening up new markets and opportunities for its goods and services.
• IMEEC will attract foreign investment and technology into India’s infrastructure sector, improving its competitiveness and efficiency.
• IMEEC will strengthen India’s strategic partnerships with key regional actors such as Saudi Arabia and the UAE, enhancing its security and influence.
• IMEEC will promote India’s soft power and cultural diplomacy in West Asia and Europe, showcasing its diversity and heritage.

What are the challenges of IMEEC?

IMEEC is not without challenges, as it faces competition from China’s OBOR as well as internal constraints. Some of the challenges include:

• IMEEC will have to contend with China’s economic clout and political leverage in West Asia and Europe, which may limit its scope and impact.
• IMEEC will have to overcome the differences and disputes among its partners on various issues such as human rights, democracy and regional conflicts.
• IMEEC will have to mobilize adequate resources and capacities to implement its projects in a timely and effective manner.

India’s new spice route is a bold move to counter China’s OBOR initiative. It reflects India’s ambition to play a leading role in shaping the global order. It also offers a viable alternative for regional integration that respects diversity and sovereignty. However, it also entails risks and responsibilities that require careful planning and execution. India will have to work closely with its partners to ensure that IMEEC delivers on its promise of mutual benefit and common good.

Read more similar topics here.